Would it’s not a physical illness which



Would you feel offended
if a doctor asked you about your sexuality? Unfortunately, the new NHS
(National Health Service in England) guidelines state that in England starting
from April 2019, doctors will ask their patients that are aged 16 or more about
their sexual preference. NHS declares that this decision is made to make sure
everyone is treated equally. Some agree with this resolution. On the contrary,
others say this will present some problems about privacy. In my opinion, the
negatives of the new guideline will outweigh the positives. Therefore, I
strongly disagree with this guideline for three reasons: The sexuality of a
patient doesn’t have an impact on his physical health, some people don’t want
to be defined by their sexuality and it’s an invasion of privacy.


Initially, doctors have
no right to know someone’s sexuality because it’s not a physical illness which
should concern doctors. Moreover, no illness is directly caused by the preference
of the sexuality and it doesn’t affect the body. However, if doctors should
know an action that’s done with the reasoning of his or her sexuality they
should only ask about the relevant action but not specifically about the
sexuality of that patient. For instance, “Doctors do not need to know our
sexuality for the vast majority of the medical conditions.” says the
Conservative MP Jacob Rees-Mogg. Also, LGB Foundation states that “Only 8% of
LGB people in Greater Manchester have never had a mental issue.” The foundation
itself says it’s a mental issue not physical. To sum up, someone’s sexuality is
a mental matter not physical, that’s why it cannot concern the doctors and they
should not ask about it.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now


Furthermore, no one
wants to be known only by their sexuality. ”I have learned to shake off the
idea that our sexual choices define us.” said Rachel Hills. Everyone’s sexuality
is a part of who they are, it’s not something to write in a document. That is
comparable to writing that a person is trustworthy or selfish with just one
word in a document that defines him instead doctors will write gay, lesbian,
straight etc. In addition, people don’t want to mention their sexual preference
in life generally, especially people who are judged because of it. Hence, being
specified with who they are by doctors would only be worse. Consequently,
defining patients only by their sexuality is completely inappropriate because
sexuality is not just one characteristic that makes up a person.


Last but not least,
it’s considered as crossing the line of privacy for a doctor to ask about
someone’s sexual orientation. “The state has got no business in our bedrooms.”
asserted Claire Fox, a panelist on BBC Radio 4’s The Moral Maze. Also, “It
sounds intrusive and Orwellian.” argued Jacob Rees-Mogg. Nobody has to
tell a stranger about his or her sexuality. Asking a question like that is
intrusive, and especially it might be embarrassing for youth. Moreover, doctors
don’t have to know everything about their patients. Considering these, someone’s
sexuality is their own privacy, it would be violating boundaries to ask someone
about it as a stranger.


In conclusion, with
these three arguments I contradict the new NHS guideline which states doctors
asking their patients about their sexualities. Sexuality of a patient isn’t a
physical situation so it should not concern the doctors, people don’t want to
be known only by their sexualities and it’s counted as an invasion of privacy
to ask about a very personal topic as a stranger; these are significant reasons
that should be considered before the new guideline comes to reality in 2019. Do
you think the new NHS guideline will improve the health services in England or
will it be a failure by being a decision that society thinks negative about and
doesn’t approve?



“Doctors to Quiz Patients on Their Sexuality.” The Day, The Day
Magazine, theday.co.uk/health/doctors-to-quiz-patients-on-their-sexuality.

Date accessed: 20.12.2017


“NHS Patients to Be Asked about Sexuality.” BBC News,
BBC, 15 Oct. 2017, www.bbc.com/news/health-41625402.


Booth, Robert. “Gay Rights Activists Welcome NHS Questioning
of Patients over Sexuality.” The Guardian, Guardian News and Media, 15
Oct. 2017, www.theguardian.com/society/2017/oct/15/patients-in-england-to-be-quizzed-over-their-sexuality.